I hadn't even gotten to writing the 5th reason for Lisa Nowak pulling her now-famous diapered assault on her romantic rival before two things occurred to me. One, I was mocking a human being who was obviously messed up. Two, I had no understanding why she did what she did.
I posted the article anyway. The whole thing deserves to be mocked, and for a very frightening reason. As fragile as the Earth's ecology is, the self-contained ecology of a space station is far more fragile. Should an astronaut on the space shuttle, International Space Station, a lunar colony, or a Mars mission wish to, destroying the environment would be trivial — and it would kill everyone. Here on Earth, I'm opposed to the death penalty. We can incarcerate people if they do something to harm others. There's much less room for tolerance in outer space. Actions which threaten the community will have to be dealt with harshly and rapidly. Deliberate attempts to destroy the environment be met with summary execution without a trial. Behavior that threatens the safety of the habitat might need to be dealt with by the harshest possible means.
Lisa Nowak's stunt reminds me of the Apollo 1 fire: she gave NASA a chance to correct a very serious flaw in its system before a tragedy occurred in outer space.
Why did Nowak act out?
A lot of reasons have been given.
- One MSNBC article lays the behavior at the feet of our need, as humans, for love.
- Similarly, Dr. Keith Ablow on the Today show discussed Nowak "losing perspective."
- An article by James Oberg on MSNBC discusses the astronaut's personal life as a source of this kind of problem — and mentions that David Walker, a shuttle commander, actually did something worse than Nowak.
- The former NASA space flight psychiatrist Terence McGuire says that everything that can be done is being done, and more would be "guilding the lily."
- Michael Hopkin's Nature article discusses the problem of detecting this pathology and mentions the problem of the "big event." Nowak worked for 10 years to fly in space, and last summer she did. What happens when you literally come back to Earth? Given the paucity of flights into space, that might have been Nowak's one chance (and I doubt she'll ever get another after what she did.
- Christopher Mim's Sciam Blog questions whether doing more might actually make the astronauts more likely to hide their pathologies and avoid help. This is the problem departmental psychiatrists and critical incident stress teams have faced for years when dealing with public safety personnel.
- Space.com (and the duplicate article over at Discovery Channel points out that there are additional pressures that female astronauts face that male astronauts don't (besides the obvious) men have much better support from their wives, where they can come home to few duties, unlike the super-career female astronauts who have to take care of their home as well as their astronautly duties.
- Three of Nowak's astronaut classmates died on the Columbia shuttle.
This explains some of the problem. But I don't think it's a full explanation. Everyone talks about how much planning went into Nowak's attack. In my joke list of wny Nowak attacked her rival, I made a subtle comment when I said "Her T-shirt says 'What would Jack Bauer do?'" As a fan of "24," I'm perhaps more aware than most how implausible a lot of "24″ is. Jack Bauer does all sorts of stunts that look brilliant on the show but would fail miserably in real life. Nowak wasn't even up to TV standards.
I shouldn't admit this, but when I heard about Nowak's assault, my first thought was how she should have done it so that it worked. A BB gun, pepper spray hammer, rubber hoses, a diaper and a wig? This wasn't some great MacGyver plan. Charging Nowak with attempted murder is giving this stunt far more credit for plausibility than it deserves. This was no plan. This was the epitome of no plan.
Think about it. She wore a diaper so she could drive 900 miles in a hurry. If you had to get 900 miles quickly, would you hop in your car? Even assuming she was driving like the mythical crazy astronaut, averaging 90 mph for the entire trip, it would still take her 10 hours to get there. Can you think of any way a Navy pilot might have covered 900 miles more quickly? Yes, that leaves a bit more evidence along the way, but if you can't figure out how to get around that, perhaps you should consider making your attack when you don't have to wear a pair of extra-strength huggies.
The way Nowak attacked was great, if she wanted to get caught. The place Nowak attacked was great, if she wanted to get caught. And you know what? She got caught.
Granted, one of the reasons I'm not the world's most feared supervillian is that, in the end, any crime scheme is far too risky for the payoff. I don't rob banks or kill people because I'm a nice guy. Even if I weren't, I wouldn't because eventually all criminal schemes wind up being hare-brained. Perhaps, because of the wig (which caused a lot of the Nolte-esque booking photo) I should say "hair-brained."
Nowak's attack on her rival, Colleen Shipman, was more likely to drive the rival and William Oefelein closer together. And guess why William Oefelein just took a leave of absence from NASA? Rather than attacking the rival, she really should have worked at making William Oefelein more interested in her. The odds are that even this wouldn't work, but at least it's legal and you don't wind up being the headlining joke for Letterman, Leno, and O'Brien.
What no one discussed is something that, while not causing Nowak's break, probably set her up for it: being an astronaut sucks. Have you ever noticed the astronauts don't have a patch on their flight jacket saying "Astronaut Local #1″? Undocumented Wal-Mart employees are treated better than NASA treats the astronauts.
There actually was a strike by NASA astronauts. Gerald Carr (no relation) led the crew of Skylab 4 (the third manned Skylab mission) in a strike when NASA's scheduling of their activities became absurd. The strike ended with more reasonable scheduling on Skylab and promises that astronaut abuse would never happen again.
Yeah, right.
When you spend hundreds of millions of dollars to put someone in orbit and there's people willing to pay tens of millions of dollars to go do it for free, abuse is the order of the day in orbit. Humans are expendable. The NASA people were all weepy about the deaths of the Challenger and Columbia astronauts, but NASA as a bureaucracy was mostly concerned with the bad PR and two terribly expensive spaceships.
Even when the astronauts are on the ground, they have to ask "How high?" to every trivial administrative request to jump. "You don't like it? Where, oh where could we possibly find someone to replace you?" Any guess how high the stack of applications is for astronaut? The NASA employment office probably has more paperwork than there's paperwork for all the tiles on the shuttles' thermal protection systems — and each tile has 30 ft. of paperwork behind it.
People talk about "critical incident stress" and how seeing bad things and doing dangerous stuff messes with your head. Speaking from my own experience, I don't think that's the real problem. Cops and medics and firefighters understand danger and tragedy and, if that were all it was, would mostly be able to deal with it. But when you just saved a life or got shot at and some supervisor comes over and starts kvetching about paperwork that wasn't filled out correctly, your ability to cope decreases. Think of the volunteer firefighters who have to beg their communities for funds so they can risk their lives — and then the people of the community complain about the firefighters asking for money.
I'm not saying public safety personnel and astronauts should be treated like kings and queens. But basic respect and decency would go a long way toward helping them deal with the stresses they encounter.
Nowak came unhinged for a number of reasons. She'd just reached the epitome of her life. Love formed under stress can be weird. Sex drags up the primitive chunks of the brain. Her lover and her husband were both abandoning her. Her friends died horrifically over Texas. Heaven only knows what happened in her childhood.
But I'll bet you good money that you would not know who Nowak is or recognize her picture if NASA treated the astronauts like human beings instead of like butt-wiping and toilet cleaning droids.
Until NASA fixes this pathology in its program, I don't think a lunar colony or mission to Mars are good ideas.